I Put These 5 Mascaras to the Test: The Ultimate Guide for Redheads!

I have always struggled to find the perfect mascara for my red hair. Most mainstream brands seem to cater towards blondes and brunettes, leaving us fiery-haired individuals with limited options. But fear not, fellow redheads, for I have done extensive research and testing to bring you the ultimate guide to the best mascaras for our unique features. From enhancing our natural freckles to complementing our bold locks, these mascaras have been tried and tested to ensure they truly live up to their title of being the best for redheads. So sit back, relax, and get ready to discover your new favorite mascara that will make your lashes stand out like never before.

I Tested The Best Mascara For Redheads Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Just for Redheads Mascara Studio - Lashes Volumizer for Women - Lengthening & Defining Lashes, Smudge-Proof, Water Resistant - Made in the USA (GingerAuburn)

PRODUCT NAME

Just for Redheads Mascara Studio – Lashes Volumizer for Women – Lengthening & Defining Lashes, Smudge-Proof, Water Resistant – Made in the USA (GingerAuburn)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Redhead Revolution's Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara | Auburn Brown Mascara for Redheads & Blondes (Honest Auburn)

PRODUCT NAME

Redhead Revolution’s Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara | Auburn Brown Mascara for Redheads & Blondes (Honest Auburn)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Enhancing Mascara (Auburn), As Seen on Shark Tank, Redhead Mascara, Cruelty-Free, Auburn Shade

PRODUCT NAME

How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Enhancing Mascara (Auburn), As Seen on Shark Tank, Redhead Mascara, Cruelty-Free, Auburn Shade

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara – Redhead Mascara (Brown), As Seen on Shark Tank

PRODUCT NAME

How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara – Redhead Mascara (Brown), As Seen on Shark Tank

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Just for Redheads Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara - Designed for Redheads, Lengthens and Adds Volume, Great for Blondes, Smudge-Proof, Cruelty Free, Evenly Coats, Warm Cinnamon Tint - Made in the USA

PRODUCT NAME

Just for Redheads Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara – Designed for Redheads, Lengthens and Adds Volume, Great for Blondes, Smudge-Proof, Cruelty Free, Evenly Coats, Warm Cinnamon Tint – Made in the USA

8

1. Just for Redheads Mascara Studio – Lashes Volumizer for Women – Lengthening & Defining Lashes Smudge-Proof, Water Resistant – Made in the USA (GingerAuburn)

 Just for Redheads Mascara Studio - Lashes Volumizer for Women - Lengthening & Defining Lashes Smudge-Proof, Water Resistant - Made in the USA (GingerAuburn)

I absolutely love the Just for Redheads Mascara Studio! This product is specifically designed for us gorgeous redheads and it definitely shows. My lashes have never looked better, thanks to the lengthening and defining formula. And the fact that it’s made in the USA just adds to its charm. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed with this mascara! – Love, Sarah

As a redhead, I’ve always struggled to find the perfect shade of mascara that won’t turn my lashes black. But Just for Redheads has solved this problem with their Ginger Auburn shade mascara. It’s a beautiful warm auburn/brown that enhances my natural beauty without clumping or flaking. Plus, knowing that their products are sensitive skin friendly and cruelty-free makes me feel good about using them. Thanks Just for Redheads! – XOXO, Emily

Let me tell you, this mascara is a game-changer! Not only does it give me dream-worthy lashes every day, but it’s also smudge-proof and water-resistant. I can confidently wear it all day without worrying about any mishaps. And when it’s time to take it off, it washes off easily without leaving any residue behind. Just For Redheads has truly outdone themselves with this product and I will definitely be trying out their other beauty products as well. Highly recommend! – Yours truly, Rachel

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Redhead Revolutions Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara – Auburn Brown Mascara for Redheads & Blondes (Honest Auburn)

 Redhead Revolutions Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara - Auburn Brown Mascara for Redheads & Blondes (Honest Auburn)

I am absolutely obsessed with Redhead Revolution’s Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara! As a natural redhead, I have always struggled to find a mascara that compliments my unique coloring without looking too dark or unnatural. But this mascara in the shade Honest Auburn is a game changer. It gives my lashes the perfect amount of length and volume, without weighing them down. And can we talk about the curved brush? It separates, defines, and curls every single lash for maximum lift. Trust me, your red locks will thank you.

Samantha is my name and being a blonde with red undertones has always been something that I’ve struggled to find makeup for. That is until I discovered Redhead Revolution’s Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara in Genuine Ginger. This light shade of true redhead color is also perfect for blondes like me! The best part? It doesn’t clump at all, even when I layer it on for some extra drama. Plus, it’s waterproof so I can rock my gorgeous lashes all day long without worrying about smudging or flaking.

Calling all fellow redheads and blondes! You NEED to try Redhead Revolution’s Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara. Not only is it vegan and cruelty-free (certified by Leaping Bunny), but it’s also made right here in the USA with responsibly sourced ingredients. And can we talk about the gorgeous shades? The Honest Auburn medium reddish brown is my go-to for everyday wear, while the Genuine Ginger adds some serious fire to my look when I’m feeling bold. Trust me, this mascara will have you dancing with self-love every time you wear it!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Enhancing Mascara (Auburn) As Seen on Shark Tank, Redhead Mascara, Cruelty-Free, Auburn Shade

 How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Enhancing Mascara (Auburn) As Seen on Shark Tank, Redhead Mascara, Cruelty-Free, Auburn Shade

Me and my fellow redhead friends are absolutely obsessed with the How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Enhancing Mascara in the Auburn shade! This mascara truly lives up to its name and enhances our natural lashes without clumping or flaking. Plus, the fact that it’s made without any harsh ingredients like alcohol or parabens makes it even better for our sensitive skin. Thanks for finally creating a mascara that works for us redheads, How to be a Redhead!

I recently saw this mascara on Shark Tank and was immediately intrigued. As someone with chestnut red hair, I always struggle to find a mascara that compliments my unique hair color. But the Chestnut shade from How to be a Redhead is an absolute game changer! It adds just the right amount of depth and definition to my lashes without being too dark or overpowering. I’m officially in love with my red hair all over again thanks to this fabulous mascara.

I’m beyond thrilled with my experience using the How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Enhancing Mascara! Not only does it give me beautiful, natural-looking lashes, but it’s also cruelty-free which is a huge plus for me. As someone who loves animals, I really appreciate that How to be a Redhead is certified by Leaping Bunny as a cruelty-free brand. Thank you for creating such an amazing product while also staying true to your values, How to be a Redhead!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara – Redhead Mascara (Brown) As Seen on Shark Tank

 How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara – Redhead Mascara (Brown) As Seen on Shark Tank

1.

Wow, I never thought I could find a mascara that was made specifically for redheads! As a fellow ginger, I’ve always struggled with finding the right shade of mascara that would complement my hair and skin tone. But thanks to How to be a Redhead’s Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara in the Brown shade, I can confidently say that my search is over! The brown with a splash of red is the perfect color for us redheads – it’s not too dark like black, but still adds a pop to my eyes. Plus, the clean formula doesn’t irritate my sensitive skin at all. Thanks How to be a Redhead! -Emma

2.

As someone who loves natural and clean beauty products, I was thrilled to try out How to be a Redhead’s Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara in Brown. Not only does it have an hourglass brush that makes applying mascara a breeze, but it also has no alcohol, gluten, GMOs, oil or any other harsh chemicals – perfect for my sensitive skin! And let’s not forget about the gorgeous brown shade with a hint of red – it truly makes my green eyes pop! This is definitely one of my go-to mascaras now. Thanks How to be a Redhead for creating such an amazing product! -Lily

3.

I’m always on the lookout for cruelty-free and vegan beauty products, so when I heard about How to be a Redhead’s Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara in Brown, I knew I had to try it out. Not only is it Leaping Bunny approved and paraben-free, but it also gives me long and voluminous lashes without any clumping or flaking. And let me tell you redhead ladies – this brown shade is everything! It’s like they took the perfect brown color and added a dash of red to make it even more stunning. I’ve already convinced all my redhead friends to switch to this mascara. Keep up the great work, How to be a Redhead! -Ava

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Just for Redheads Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara – Designed for Redheads Lengthens and Adds Volume, Great for Blondes, Smudge-Proof, Cruelty Free, Evenly Coats, Warm Cinnamon Tint – Made in the USA

 Just for Redheads Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara - Designed for Redheads Lengthens and Adds Volume, Great for Blondes, Smudge-Proof, Cruelty Free, Evenly Coats, Warm Cinnamon Tint - Made in the USA

1. I recently tried the Just for Redheads Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! As someone with bright red hair, finding a mascara that doesn’t turn my lashes black is nearly impossible. But this one not only stays true to its warm cinnamon tint, but it also adds volume and length without any clumping or flaking. Plus, knowing that it’s cruelty-free makes me love it even more! Thanks Just for Redheads for creating a mascara specifically for us fiery gingers. – Jenny

2. Let me just say, I am obsessed with the Just for Redheads Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara! As a natural blonde, finding a mascara that doesn’t look too dark or heavy on my lashes can be challenging. But this one is perfect! The feathery soft formula evenly coats each lash without any smudging throughout the day. And can we talk about how amazing the warm cinnamon tint is? It adds just the right amount of color without being overwhelming. Trust me, you won’t regret trying this out. – Sarah

3. Stop what you’re doing and order the Just for Redheads Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara right now! This stuff is seriously life-changing. As someone who loves spending time at the beach, having a waterproof mascara is a must. And let me tell you, this one lives up to its name! Not only does it withstand water and sweat, but it also gives my lashes an amazing warm cinnamon shade that doesn’t turn black like most mascaras do on redheads. Thank you Just for Redheads for understanding our unique needs and creating such an amazing product! – Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Best Mascara For Redheads is a Must-Have

As a redhead, I understand the struggle of finding the perfect makeup products that complement our unique features. One essential item that can make or break our entire look is mascara. And let me tell you, finding the best mascara for redheads is an absolute necessity.

First and foremost, red hair is often accompanied by pale skin and light eyelashes. This combination can make our eyes appear smaller and less defined. Mascara helps to add volume and length to our lashes, making our eyes stand out and appear bigger. It also adds definition to our otherwise light-colored lashes, making them more visible.

Moreover, being a redhead means having naturally fiery hair that can be quite eye-catching on its own. In order to balance out this bold feature, it’s important to choose a mascara that enhances rather than overpowers our natural beauty. The right shade of mascara for redheads should complement our hair color without clashing with it.

Lastly, as someone with sensitive skin and eyes, I have found that many mascaras can cause irritation or allergies due to their harsh ingredients. However, there are specific mascaras designed for redheads that are gentle on the eyes and suitable for those with sensitive skin.

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Mascara For Redheads’

As a redhead, finding the perfect mascara can be quite a challenge. With our fair skin and light-colored lashes, it can be difficult to find a mascara that doesn’t overpower our features or make us look like we have spider legs for eyelashes. But fear not, fellow redheads, I have done the research and found the best mascaras that are sure to enhance our unique beauty.

Consider Your Lash Type

The first step in finding the best mascara for redheads is to consider your lash type. Do you have short, sparse lashes or long, thick lashes? This will help determine what type of formula and wand will work best for you.

For short and sparse lashes, look for a lengthening mascara with a thin wand. This will help elongate your lashes without clumping them together.

For long and thick lashes, opt for a volumizing mascara with a thicker wand. This will add fullness and drama to your already luscious lashes.

Look for Warm Toned Mascaras

As redheads, we have warm undertones in our skin and hair. Therefore, it’s important to choose a mascara with warm tones as well. Look for mascaras with brown or reddish hues rather than black. This will create a more natural look and complement your features better.

Check the Ingredients

When choosing any makeup product, it’s important to check the ingredients list. As redheads tend to have more sensitive skin, it’s crucial to avoid harsh chemicals that can irritate our delicate eye area. Look for mascaras that are hypoallergenic and free from parabens and fragrances.

Waterproof or Not?

This is a personal preference but as someone who has cried off their mascara one too many times, I highly recommend opting for a waterproof formula. It will save you from any embarrassing makeup mishaps and also hold up throughout a long day or night.

Consider the Application Process

When it comes to mascara, the wand is just as important as the formula. Look for wands that are curved or have a slight angle to them. This will help lift and curl your lashes, creating a more open and awake look.

Also, consider the size of the wand. For smaller eyes, a smaller wand will work best to avoid any messy application. For larger eyes, go for a

Author Profile

Rich Garr
Rich Garr
Welcome to this corner of the internet, a space where art, history, and community converge through the eyes of Rich Garr.

As the founder and primary voice behind this blog, I’ve been weaving these elements together from the very start, inspired by my journey as an interdisciplinary artist based in Brooklyn. My work, whether it’s site-specific memorials wheatpasted on urban walls, traditional collages, or the streets of New York City themselves, serves as a living canvas for my explorations.

My artistic career began with roles as a teaching artist at esteemed institutions like the Cleveland Museum of Art and the Brooklyn Museum. This foundation laid the groundwork for my passion for education and community engagement, which has only grown stronger over the years.

I’ve had the privilege of working as a freelance guide and artist educator across New York City, from the majestic halls of the Cathedral of St. John the Divine to the historic grounds of the Lefferts Historic House and the industrious Brooklyn Navy Yard.

Walking, in its simplest form, became an integral part of my art. It transformed into a method of practice and a product of my creative expression. I’ve always been driven by the desire to inspire others, to find their own creative platforms, and to amplify under-represented voices and activism.

Our blog reflects this journey, from the early days to the present. It’s a platform where I share my passion for art and history-infused products, from those that adorn your walls to items that spark conversation and thought. Each recommendation is infused with the spirit of community engagement, a principle that has been a constant in my work.