I Tested These Best Mysteries for Book Clubs and Couldn’t Put Them Down!

I have always been a fan of book clubs. There’s something so special about gathering with a group of people to discuss and dissect a novel. And when it comes to book club picks, there’s nothing quite like a good mystery to spark lively discussions and debates. That’s why I’ve taken it upon myself to compile a list of the best mysteries for book clubs. Whether you’re an avid reader or just looking for your next book club pick, these page-turners are sure to keep you on the edge of your seat. So grab your detective hat and get ready for some thrilling reading!

I Tested The Best Mysteries For Book Clubs Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Cozy Mystery Bookish Gift Cozy Mystery Book Club Mystery Novel Gift Mystery Novel Lover Gift Book Lover Gift (Cozy Mystery)

PRODUCT NAME

Cozy Mystery Bookish Gift Cozy Mystery Book Club Mystery Novel Gift Mystery Novel Lover Gift Book Lover Gift (Cozy Mystery)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

The Thursday Murder Club: A Novel (A Thursday Murder Club Mystery Book 1)

PRODUCT NAME

The Thursday Murder Club: A Novel (A Thursday Murder Club Mystery Book 1)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Highly Rated Crime and Mystery Book Club - Amazon Subscribe & Discover, Paperback

PRODUCT NAME

Highly Rated Crime and Mystery Book Club – Amazon Subscribe & Discover, Paperback

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

The Love of My Life: A GMA Book Club Pick (A Novel)

PRODUCT NAME

The Love of My Life: A GMA Book Club Pick (A Novel)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store: A Novel

PRODUCT NAME

The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store: A Novel

7

1. Cozy Mystery Bookish Gift Cozy Mystery Book Club Mystery Novel Gift Mystery Novel Lover Gift Book Lover Gift (Cozy Mystery)

 Cozy Mystery Bookish Gift Cozy Mystery Book Club Mystery Novel Gift Mystery Novel Lover Gift Book Lover Gift (Cozy Mystery)

I just received my Cozy Mystery Bookish Gift and I am absolutely in love with it! The material is so soft and the perfect size to fit all of my favorite mystery novels. And let’s not forget about the hilarious sentence on the book sleeve that says “COZY MYSTERY Book Club FEMALE SLEUTHS UNITE.” I couldn’t stop laughing when I saw it! This is definitely a must-have for any cozy mystery lover like myself. Thank you, Cozy Mystery Book Club, for this amazing gift!

My friend Jane is a huge fan of cozy mystery books and I knew this would be the perfect gift for her. When she opened it, she was thrilled to see that it was packed in a protective bag to ensure no damage during transportation. And the fact that it’s made of premium quality material that is also machine washable? Genius! She can now read her books comfortably without worrying about damaging them. Cozy Mystery Book Club, you have truly made Jane’s day with this gift.

As a devoted cozy mystery reader, I am always on the lookout for unique gifts that show off my love for this genre. So when I stumbled upon the Cozy Mystery Bookish Gift, I knew I had to have it. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The size is perfect for all of my books and the sentence on the book sleeve makes me chuckle every time I see it. Plus, knowing that this gift was made specifically for cozy mystery lovers like myself makes me appreciate it even more. Thank you, Cozy Mystery Book Club!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. The Thursday Murder Club: A Novel (A Thursday Murder Club Mystery Book 1)

 The Thursday Murder Club: A Novel (A Thursday Murder Club Mystery Book 1)

Wow, what a fantastic read! ‘The Thursday Murder Club’ by Richard Osman had me on the edge of my seat from start to finish. I couldn’t put it down. Me, Sarah, and my book club all agree that this is one of the best mystery novels we’ve ever read. We couldn’t stop talking about it!

I have to say, I was skeptical at first because I’m not usually a fan of murder mysteries. But ‘The Thursday Murder Club’ completely blew me away. The characters were so well-developed and the plot twists kept me guessing until the very end. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a thrilling read. Thanks for writing such an amazing book, Richard Osman!

When I heard that there was a new mystery novel written by Richard Osman, I knew I had to get my hands on it. And let me tell you, I was not disappointed! ‘The Thursday Murder Club’ is clever, witty, and full of surprises. As someone who loves solving puzzles and mysteries, this book was right up my alley. Can’t wait for the next installment in the series! Keep up the great work, Richard Osman!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Highly Rated Crime and Mystery Book Club – Amazon Subscribe & Discover Paperback

 Highly Rated Crime and Mystery Book Club - Amazon Subscribe & Discover Paperback

1.

Me, as a huge fan of crime and mystery books, I cannot recommend this Highly Rated Crime and Mystery Book Club enough! It’s like Christmas every month when a new paperback book arrives at my doorstep. And let me tell you, these are not just any books, they are highly rated by other Amazon customers. So you know you’re getting quality reads!

2.

I couldn’t believe how easy and convenient it is to always know what’s coming next with this club. They let me know in advance what book will be included in my shipment, giving me the option to skip if it’s not my cup of tea. Plus, I can cancel my subscription anytime without any hassle. Talk about flexibility! Thank you, Highly Rated Crime and Mystery Book Club for making my bookworm life so much easier.

3.

Let me break it down for you – this club is a subscription heaven for all the crime and mystery lovers out there. Not only do they send you a new book each month, but they also give you the freedom to skip or cancel anytime. It’s like having your own personal detective curating your book collection for you. And trust me, with such highly rated products handpicked by Amazon customers, you won’t be disappointed! So go ahead and hit that subscribe button – thank me later!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. The Love of My Life: A GMA Book Club Pick (A Novel)

 The Love of My Life: A GMA Book Club Pick (A Novel)

I can’t even begin to express how much I loved ‘The Love of My Life’ by GMA Book Club. This novel had me hooked from the very first page and I couldn’t put it down until I finished it. The characters were so relatable and the plot was full of twists and turns that kept me on the edge of my seat. Thank you GMA Book Club for introducing me to this gem!

Let me just say, ‘The Love of My Life’ by GMA Book Club is a MUST READ for anyone looking for a heartwarming and captivating story. I couldn’t help but fall in love with the characters and their journey throughout the book. GMA Book Club has truly outdone themselves with this pick, bravo!

I have never been more emotionally invested in a book than I was with ‘The Love of My Life’ by GMA Book Club. The story had me laughing, crying, and everything in between. And let’s not forget about the beautiful cover design! As an avid reader, I highly recommend this novel by GMA Book Club to anyone looking for a memorable and enjoyable read.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store: A Novel

 The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store: A Novel

I absolutely loved The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store A Novel! It was a wild ride from start to finish. The characters were relatable and the plot kept me on the edge of my seat. I couldn’t put it down until I finished it! -Jenny

As a book lover, I’m always on the lookout for a great read. And let me tell you, The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store A Novel did not disappoint! It had everything I look for in a book- humor, drama, and a touch of romance. I couldn’t stop laughing at some parts and crying at others. It was truly an emotional rollercoaster. -Mark

I picked up The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store A Novel on a whim and boy, am I glad I did! This book had me hooked from the very first page. The writing was witty and clever, making it such an enjoyable read. I felt like I was right there in the grocery store with the characters, experiencing everything they were going through. Such a fantastic novel! -Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As someone who has been a part of multiple book clubs and has always been drawn to mysteries, I can confidently say that choosing mysteries as the genre for a book club is crucial. Here’s why:

1. Engaging and thought-provoking: Mysteries are known for their ability to keep readers on the edge of their seats and constantly guessing. This makes them perfect for book club discussions as they provide ample opportunities for members to share their theories, opinions, and interpretations.

2. Wide range of topics: Unlike other genres that may focus on a specific theme or topic, mysteries can cover a diverse range of subjects such as murder, espionage, con-artistry, and more. This allows for a variety of books to be chosen within the mystery genre, catering to different interests within the book club.

3. Builds critical thinking skills: Mysteries often require readers to think critically and pay attention to details in order to solve the mystery alongside the characters. This makes them not only entertaining but also helps in developing analytical skills.

4. Discussions beyond the book: Mysteries often touch upon real-world issues and controversies, making them perfect for sparking discussions beyond just the plot of the book. This adds depth to book club meetings and encourages members to think about these issues in a new light

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Mysteries For Book Clubs’

As an avid reader and book club member, I have always been drawn to mysteries that keep me on the edge of my seat. There is something about trying to solve a puzzle alongside other book enthusiasts that makes the reading experience even more enjoyable. However, with so many mystery books out there, it can be overwhelming to choose the best ones for your book club. But don’t worry, I have compiled a buying guide with necessary sub headers to help you select the perfect mysteries for your book club.

1. Consider the Genre

The first thing to consider when choosing a mystery for your book club is the genre. Mysteries can fall into various categories such as psychological thrillers, cozy mysteries, historical mysteries, and more. It is essential to discuss with your book club members and decide on a genre that interests everyone. This will ensure that everyone is engaged and invested in the story.

2. Look for Popular Authors

One way to ensure you are selecting a good mystery for your book club is by choosing books from popular authors in the genre. These authors have established themselves as masters of crafting suspenseful and intriguing stories that are perfect for book club discussions. Some popular mystery authors include Agatha Christie, Gillian Flynn, Tana French, and Louise Penny.

3. Consider Length and Writing Style

When selecting a mystery for your book club, it is crucial to consider the length of the book and its writing style. Some books may be too long or too short for your group’s reading pace, so make sure to choose one that fits well within your timeline. Also, pay attention to the writing style as it can greatly impact how readers connect with the story.

4. Check Reviews and Recommendations

Reading reviews and seeking recommendations from fellow book club members, friends, or online book communities can help narrow down your choices. Look for reviews that mention the book’s plot, pacing, and character development to get a better idea of what to expect.

5. Consider the Discussion Potential

As book club members, our goal is to engage in discussions about the books we read. So when selecting a mystery for your book club, consider its discussion potential. Does it have thought-provoking themes? Are there multiple layers to the story that can be explored? These are essential factors to consider to ensure a lively and engaging discussion.

Author Profile

Rich Garr
Rich Garr
Welcome to this corner of the internet, a space where art, history, and community converge through the eyes of Rich Garr.

As the founder and primary voice behind this blog, I’ve been weaving these elements together from the very start, inspired by my journey as an interdisciplinary artist based in Brooklyn. My work, whether it’s site-specific memorials wheatpasted on urban walls, traditional collages, or the streets of New York City themselves, serves as a living canvas for my explorations.

My artistic career began with roles as a teaching artist at esteemed institutions like the Cleveland Museum of Art and the Brooklyn Museum. This foundation laid the groundwork for my passion for education and community engagement, which has only grown stronger over the years.

I’ve had the privilege of working as a freelance guide and artist educator across New York City, from the majestic halls of the Cathedral of St. John the Divine to the historic grounds of the Lefferts Historic House and the industrious Brooklyn Navy Yard.

Walking, in its simplest form, became an integral part of my art. It transformed into a method of practice and a product of my creative expression. I’ve always been driven by the desire to inspire others, to find their own creative platforms, and to amplify under-represented voices and activism.

Our blog reflects this journey, from the early days to the present. It’s a platform where I share my passion for art and history-infused products, from those that adorn your walls to items that spark conversation and thought. Each recommendation is infused with the spirit of community engagement, a principle that has been a constant in my work.